Ecommerce Platform Review: Sellfy

If you have something that others want, it's never been easier to monetize it. To help, look no further than ecommerce platforms, which allow anyone, even those without the faintest idea of programming or web design, to quickly and easily create a professional-looking online store in a short amount of time. One provider that promises to make this as stress-free as possible is Sellfy.

What is Sellfy?

Sellfy is a cloud-based ecommerce platform that allows pretty much anyone to create an online store and peddle their wares. The company targets one group in particular, namely 'creatives', authors, designers, musicians, or directors, who can sell their creations on Sellfy with relative ease.

In this review, we'll take a look at whether Sellfy is really so hassle-free as it claims to be, and what sets it apart from other, similar, ecommerce platforms.

Review

Review Score
3.7 / 5
11/2020
good
Visit Website
Configuration & Usage
4.7 / 5
Support
4.3 / 5
Generating Sales
3.7 / 5
Marketing & Analytics
3.7 / 5
Product Management
3.0 / 5
Personalizing Your Store
3.0 / 5
1.

Pros and Cons

Easy to use, especially for beginners

Adding products is straightforward

Specially designed for selling digital products

Few abilities to personalize/customize your store

Limited features and settings in comparison to other platforms

Little support for physical products and no delivery/shipping assistance

2.

Configuration & Usage

Like most ecommerce platforms, Sellfy offers a free test version, which doesn't require the input of payment information. As such, registering is a breeze: Simply click on Start Free Trial on the service's homepage, enter your email address, set a password, and name your store. Then, answer a few questions about your store and the expected number of customers. After that, you're already in the dashboard.

Sellfy promises to help sell products hassle-free, but is it really so easy?

When you enter the user interface for the first time, the Setup Assistant will help you to create your online store. First, you'll be taken to the product management section, followed by the design section, payment settings, and for the grand finale, an advertisement for upgrading to the service's paid version.

Before you take this step, we'll walk you through the service as we experienced it. The dashboard makes a good impression, with all navigation occurring through the blue sidebar to the left, which contains sections titled Overview, Products, Orders, Marketing, Apps, and Store Settings.

In the bottom left, by clicking on Account, a menu will open, in which you can edit your account settings, payment details, and contact options.

The service's Setup Assistant takes you through the first steps of using Sellfy.

By selecting Overview and clicking on View my store you'll be taken directly to your online store. Here, in the Analytics area, you can find a summary of statistics, as well as an overview of your customers and subscriptions/orders.

The overview provides you with all the most important information about your online store, orders, and customers.

By clicking on Store Settings you can adjust basic aspects of your store, such as its main currency, the number of payment options available, and taxes. In addition, you'll be able to edit the default email that is sent to customers after making a purchase.

After just a few minutes of use, it became pretty clear to us that Sellfy really wants to appeal to as many types of users as possible, removing all hurdles to this. The platform's learning curve is flat, and we're certain that even the most inexperienced user will just need a short while to get acquainted with the online store platform.

For our tastes, how different features are grouped together doesn't always follow a clear logic - for example, product categories are created under general settings, instead of in the product/inventory area. With that said, there's no doubt in our minds that Sellfy is user-friendly.

Score: 4.7 / 5

3.

Personalizing Your Store

You can access the site builder for your store by clicking on Store Settings > Customization. Here, Sellfy's ease of use shows its first lapse, namely, a complete absence of templates. Whereas other platforms provide a variety of designs users can choose from, Sellfy has only a single basic template on offer.

Using the drop-down menu in the upper left, it's possible to jump between the different pages of your store and to create new subpages. Each new page appears automatically in the menu bar.

In the pages menu, you'll find the content blocks for each page: Hero blocks for catchy images, text blocks, product blocks, as well as newsletter and contact forms. The position of these blocks in your store is determined by their arrangement in the menu. It's possible to drag and drop menu items or product types directly on the page.

The store builder has some drag and drop functionality, but not much.

In the upper menu bar, it's also possible to switch between the web and mobile views of your store, to check how it appears in different formats. By clicking on Publish, any changes you've made will go public, after which you'll receive a link to your now-finished store. There, you can navigate through your store as a regular customer might, but thanks to the buttons in the dashboard, can also add or make changes to some content (i.e., add new products).

It's possible to preview your site as a customer and make minimal changes to it.

On the plus side, it's really difficult to muck up a lot in Sellfy's store builder. Unfortunately, this comes almost entirely at the cost of your creative/design freedom, and the ability to personalize your store.

Images, colors, fonts, and menus can be edited, and it's also possible to add different subpages. The uncomplicated nature of the default template also ensures that by adding different elements, it's possible to create a store that fits your needs. With that said, don't get your hopes up of breaking the mold.

For us, Sellfy is a lot like bowling with bumpers or riding a bicycle with training wheels. Beginners, in particular, will appreciate the ability to create a nice-looking online store, without having to worry about all of the frills (and dangers) that can be associated with this. Our issue with Sellfy is that it wouldn't be difficult to provide this, and still offer enhanced design options, such as, for example, more templates to choose from.

Score: 3 / 5

4.

Product Management

Managing products is possible through the similarly named submenu. Here, you can select from digital products, freebies, subscriptions, and physical products. If you want to add a new product, it's necessary to select which type it is.

Also included is a Print On Demand feature, which allows you to offer personalized items like t-shirts or coffee mugs. Unfortunately, as of the time of our review, this was still in an "Invite only" test phase.

You can select from four different product types, with a fifth, "Print On Demand", currently being tested.

Creating a product is fairly straightforward. Simply name your item, describe it, and set a price (for subscriptions, include a payment cycle), upload images of the product, and if desired, specify which category the good should be assigned to. After this, all you'll need to do is input your delivery region and, optionally, an in-stock quantity before you start selling.

We found the "Pay What You Want" feature to be a nice touch since it allows customers to set a sale price (you can input a minimum price). Particularly when starting out, this feature is useful for drawing visitors to your store.

When adding digital products an upload window will appear in the product area. Here, Sellfy is fairly generous in comparison to other solutions, allowing files with a size of up to 10 GB to be uploaded.

Creating a new product just takes a few clicks.

It's also possible to add different variations of each product, including unique names, images, and prices. The ease of doing this, like that of designing your store, brings with it a few disadvantages as well.

For example, it isn't possible to combine variations, meaning that you need to create a new variation for each color/size combination of clothing items. Customers will select such items from a single drop-down menu, rather than two side-by-side boxes, or charts, which if offering a lot of sizes and color options, can create an unwieldy menu.

Adding new products is easy, but creating variations of them is tedious.

Especially when set alongside other ecommerce platforms that offer the ability to create lots of different product combinations in one fell swoop, Sellfy's support for variations is a bit underwhelming. We're certain that those selling apparel will probably look elsewhere when thinking about moving their business online. Making this even worse is the inability to add further information to items, such as their weight, or tax. User-defined fields displaying this cannot be created.

Managing your products in Sellfy isn't particularly complicated, but don't expect to have a lot of options.

Since Sellfy isn't geared towards selling physical products, it doesn't offer much in the way of inventory either. It's necessary to manually enter the quantity available for each product variation. Once sold out, customers won't be able to add the product to their shopping cart. That's it - tracking, deliveries of new stock, or automations can't be readily integrated into the inventory section.

Of course, it is somewhat unfair to compare Sellfy with much larger all-around solutions that offer a completely free hand when adding new products. This not least because those platforms have a much steeper learning curve, whereas Sellfy is basically a once and done solution, meaning that you only need to do everything one time to get started selling. As such, its appeal to beginners shouldn't be minimized to any degree.

So far, wherever we've looked, Sellfy's focus has been on simplicity, with this translating into digital goods and products not offered in multiple variations. If you're in the market to offer downloads quickly and efficiently to your audience, Sellfy will certainly fulfill your needs. But, if you want to sell physical goods, such as apparel or computer products, the limitations can and will sap your love for the service.

Score: 3 / 5

5.

Generating Sales

To sell the products that you've so carefully added to your store, you'll need to configure your payment options. This can be done by clicking on Store Settings > Payment Settings. The selection of providers isn't particularly large, with PayPal and Stripe the only two services which offer card payments. Of course, considering how prevalent these are in the digital landscape, less isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Payments can be made on Sellfy with either PayPal or Stripe.

Turning to shipping/delivery options, Sellfy's digital focus again becomes all-too apparent. As noted above, when adding products, it's possible to input the delivery region(s) and their respective costs. Here, you can enter two prices: The shipping cost when the article is ordered on its own, and the additional costs if it's part of a larger shipment.

Sellfy isn't integrated with any delivery or logistics services. This contrasts with other ecommerce platforms that include live pricing from companies like DHL, FedEx, or UPS. With Sellfy, you'll have to handle this entirely on your own.

If you want to ship physical products, Sellfy doesn't provide much in the way of support.

Tax settings can be found by clicking on Store settings > Tax settings. Basically, Sellfy automatically calculates tax, however, it isn't possible to manually create different tax regions, as is the case with most other ecommerce platforms. As something of a trade-off, you can choose whether to show before-tax or after-tax prices to your customers, and whether or not to tax delivery.

Orders can be found in the Orders submenu. All of the purchases customers have made from your store are listed here, with the ability to sort them by the date when they were made, as well as search through them on the basis of their email address or individual items. For each order, you're also shown the delivery date, the product, the email address of the buyer, the order status, and the total price.

By clicking on an order, you'll be given additional information. This includes a timeline of when the order was made as well as any changes or updates that have occurred since then. For digital products, it's possible to re-send emails containing download links if customers have requested them. For physical orders, you'll be able to view the customer's email address.

Each order is marked in the relevant submenu.

English comes pre-installed as Sellfy's store language. To create a store in another language, you'll need to change the main language. Simply go to Store Settings > General Settings and set the Store Language. All ready-made/default texts will be automatically translated, while any content which you've added in English, will have to be translated manually into the localization's language.

You can also set the language to Automatic which changes it based on the language used by your site's visitors.

Even though Sellfy's dashboard is set to English by default, it's possible to change your store's language.

Unfortunately, Sellfy doesn't offer the ability to integrate additional sales channels like Facebook Shop or Amazon.

Overall, so far as sales are concerned, Sellfy again shows both strengths and weaknesses, but they follow the trend established in the previous section: If you're selling digital products, Sellfy has got your back; if you're selling anything else, you're likely to be on your own either in part or entirely.

Another complaint, albeit much smaller, is that the payment options with Sellfy are a bit more limited than those of other providers. In the plusses column is definitely the service's support for multiple language localizations.

Score: 3.7 / 5

6.

Marketing & Analytics

By clicking on Marketing > Email Marketing you can launch an email campaign with a minimum of effort, dispatching it to all recipients or specific groups (all customers of a product, or just newsletter subscribers). Each email costs a Credit, which you'll receive starting with the Business package (more on prices below).

Email templates are provided for three different scenarios (new product launch, discount, or a product update) as is the ability to create a new message from scratch. In comparison to dedicated services, Sellfy's functionality is definitely rudimentary, however, we still look favorably upon the inclusion of email marketing at all, since we encountered enough providers that don't have integrated solutions.

With Sellfy's integrated email marketing it's possible to inform your customers about a new product or discount.

It's also possible to surprise your customers with a discount or markdown on individual products (if you want to put an entire category on sale, you'll need to reduce the price of each individual item). By clicking on Coupons & Discounts, you can quickly set up coupons and sales.

So far as discount codes or vouchers are concerned, these must be set in percent and can be optionally given a validity period and usage limit. For special sales, you can add a countdown timer to help motivate your customers.

Sellfy's options are again somewhat limited when set alongside those of its competitors. For example, discounts can only be offered in percents, and not lump sums. Automations, such as welcome coupons, aren't offered either.

In Sellfy, you can create coupons and discounts, albeit only in percents.

Sellfy's Upselling feature, which is made available for Business subscribers and above, is worth mentioning here. This allows you to automatically recommend an additional, discounted product to customers, depending on what items are in their shopping cart.

Comprehensive SEO features aren't offered, however, your online store is already optimized for search engines by default, which you can improve by adding slugs to your products.

Analytics

Statistics can be found by clicking on Overview > Analytics. Here, you can keep tabs on your visitors, as well as customers, by monitoring their conversion rate and browsing behavior. You can also track your orders and see which products have generated the most profit. In addition, you can see how visitors find your site, and where they are located.

Sellfy's analytics keep you informed about how many visitors your store has, as well as how likely they are to place orders.

Like elsewhere, Sellfy's options are a bit less impressive than those of its competitors. For example, no information about returning customers or average order amounts is provided. If you need or want more statistics for your store, you can integrate Google Analytics, Facebook Pixel, or Twitter Conversion Tracking, through the Apps section.

If you need more statistics, you can get these by integrating third-party apps.

As above, Sellfy provides a decent range of options and features, however, lags far behind its bigger competitors.

Score: 3.7 / 5

7.

Support

By clicking on the magnifying glass in the bottom right, and then selecting an area of the dashboard, you can view relevant articles and guides. Clicking will open a specific article in a mini-window. This is especially convenient since it means you won't need to leave the dashboard to fix any issue you might be having. It would be nice if an option was available to open certain help articles in an additional browser tab, since going back and forth between the mini-window and the dashboard can become annoying.

Of course, you can also read the same article in the help center. The articles themselves are well-written, contain screenshots, info-boxes, and links.

Sellfy's support team can be contacted directly through the dashboard.

To get in touch with Sellfy's support team, click on Account > Contact Us. In the window that opens, you'll only need to enter your message, and, if desired, include a screenshot. After that, click send, and a support ticket will be opened. We received an extremely helpful answer to our query after just a few minutes.

Additional contact options, such as a hotline or live chat, aren't available. Premium subscribers are given priority support.

Score: 4.3 / 5

8.

Pricing

Sellfy is available in three different subscription packages: Starter, Business, and Premium. Each subscription can be paid either monthly or yearly. As of the time of writing, a yearly subscription provides a discount of 34%.

In all packages, you can add as many products as you'd like, and won't have to pay any transaction fees. Instead, there are annual sales limits - $10,000 for Starters, $50,000 for Business, and $200,000 for Premium subscribers. If you plan on selling more, Sellfy will create a specialized plan based on your needs.

These aren't the only differences between subscriptions though. Sellfy's branding is visible in the Starter subscription. The Business subscription removes this, while unlocking the upselling feature, and providing you with 10,000 email credits for sending marketing emails.

Premium subscribers get all of the Business features, as well as an additional 40,000 email credits, and priority support.

An overview of all subscription packages can be found here:

StarterBusinessPremium
Pricing
Price per month $19.00 $39.00 $89.00
Transaction Fee 0 % 0 % 0 %
Contract period (months) 12 12 12
Product Management
Number of Products unlimited unlimited unlimited
Product Filters
Product Variants
Product Reviews
Digital Products
Features
Multilingual
Multiple Currencies
Sales Channels
-
-
-
Payment Options
PayPal
Stripe
PayPal
Stripe
PayPal
Stripe

Conclusion

Review Score
3.7 / 5
11/2020
good
Visit Website
Configuration & Usage
4.7 / 5
Support
4.3 / 5
Generating Sales
3.7 / 5
Marketing & Analytics
3.7 / 5
Product Management
3.0 / 5
Personalizing Your Store
3.0 / 5

Wrapping up this review, we again want to make it clear that comparing Sellfy to the other ecommerce platforms we looked at in our EXPERTE.com review series is somewhat unfair. As the 'hobbyist/artist' among the group, Sellfy comes up short in nearly every area: Selling physical products is made significantly more difficult, owing not only to how time-consuming it is to add multiple variations, but also the absence of any help whatsoever in terms of shipping or delivery. But that's not all, the service's design options are greatly limited and analytics aren't so informative as those of other providers.

However, for anyone selling digital products, the platform excels, outpacing its more well-established rivals. Similarly, its user-friendliness can't be beaten, with the ability to create and open a store in the same amount of time others would need to learn the ins and outs of the store builder alone. In that spirit, if you're selling digital products, we highly recommend Sellfy.

Sellfy
(84)
focus on digital products
super easy to use
hard to customize
Number of Products
unlimited
Transaction Fee
0 %
Sales Channels
1
Payment Options
2+
Sellfy Starter
$19.00
monthly price
Visit Website »
14 day free trial
Review Score
3.7 / 5
good

Customer Reviews

Here, we've summarized what customers and users are saying about Sellfy.

Customer Rating
4.0 / 5
84 Ratings
good
We analyzed the reviews and ratings from various portals and found 84 ratings with an overall rating of 4.0 out of 5 .
Show sources

Alternatives

Should you want a platform that makes selling digital products as easy as Sellfy, but also provides the ability to peddle physical ones as well, with significantly more design freedom, you can't go wrong with our overall winner, Wix.

If personalizing your store isn't at the top of your list of priorities, but you want to sell physical products in addition to your digital offerings, Shopify or BigCommerce are definitely worth checking out.

Further alternatives to Sellfy can be found here:

Wix Stores
(73,639)
suitable for beginners
intuitive user interface
great design freedom
fast support
Wix builds on its strengths as a website builder and adds great sales and marketing features. This makes Wix especially suitable for ambitious beginners.
Number of Products
50,000 Products
Transaction Fee
0 %
Sales Channels
5+
Payment Options
4+
Wix Business Basic
$22.81
monthly price
Visit Website »
14 day free trial
Review Score
4.6 / 5
excellent
BigCommerce
(813)
intuitive handling
great product management
lots of marketing features
no product limit
difficult to localize
BigCommerce is a powerful ecommerce platform with a well-designed product management, many sales channels and solid analytics features. It is especially suitable for more complex ecommerce projects.
Number of Products
unlimited
Transaction Fee
0 %
Sales Channels
7+
Payment Options
6+
BigCommerce Standard
$29.95
monthly price
Visit Website »
Start Free Trial
Review Score
4.4 / 5
good
Shopify
(7,606)
for small and big stores
easy to use
large app store
great support website
Shopify is refreshingly uncomplicated and cleverly packs many features into a user-friendly dashboard. Flexible extensions make it suitable for larger stores as well.
Number of Products
unlimited
Transaction Fee
0.5 - 2 %
Sales Channels
7+
Payment Options
7+
Shopify Basic
$29.00
monthly price
Visit Website »
14 day free trial
Review Score
4.3 / 5
good
1&1 IONOS eCommerce
(14,104)
simple product management
multilingual stores possible
fast support with live chat
powerful website editor
1&1 IONOS takes Ecwid's powerful ecommerce software and complements it with its in-house website builder. The result is a solid ecommerce platform that is also suitable for advanced users.
Number of Products
5,000 - ∞
Transaction Fee
0 %
Sales Channels
5+
Payment Options
4+
1&1 IONOS Online Store
$23.96
monthly price
Visit Website »
First Month Free
Review Score
4.3 / 5
good
Lightspeed
(1,174)
easy to use
lots of templates
easy multilingual setup
limited number of products
Number of Products
250 - 15,000
Transaction Fee
0 %
Sales Channels
3+
Payment Options
4+
Lightspeed Starter
$99.00
monthly price
Visit Website »
14 days free trial
Review Score
4.1 / 5
good
Author Janis von Bleichert
Janis von Bleichert studied business informatics at the TU Munich and computer science at the TU Berlin, Germany. He has been self-employed since 2006 and is the founder of EXPERTE.com. He writes about hosting, software and IT security.
Other languages:
Deutsch